Chromatography 17.3
Describe how you have carried out a chromatography experiment. [P4]
Aim
- Use chromatography to analyse pigment from leaves.
Method
- The leaves are cut into small pieces and deposited into the mortar. A small amount of sand is then added to enable the grinding process. Propanol is also added.
- A pencil line on a strip of chromatography paper is drawn 2cm from the bottom.
- A capillary tube is used to collect a small sample of the resulting mush made from grinding in a mortar leaves, salt and propanol.
- The sample is deposited on one point on the pencil line, and then the paper is inserted into a boiling tube filled with around 1.5cm cube of propanol.
- The result are observed and noted.
Results
Spinach leaves: Results
Pigment – 5 cm 5/6 = 8.3
Propanol – 6 cm
Y leaves: Results
Pigment – 1.5 cm 1.5/6 = 0.25
Propanol – 6 cm
Class results (spinach)*
0.5/0.6
0.81
0.84/0.41
0.67
0.72
0.75
*Each of these results were obtained independently from ours i.e. they were six groups of 2 students whose results are listed above.
Conclusion
From our results we found that the spinach leaves dissipated much more than the y leaves, indicating that the pigment from the spinach leaves has a much higher retention factor than the y leaves. Thus using propanone is it will be easier to remove the spinach pigment if it were in the form of a stain as in described by the scenario.
Demonstrate how chromatography works, including specific details as to what would happen if two pigments matched up.[M4]
Chromatography is used to separate mixtures and identify the different colouring agents found in chemicals. In order to achieve this, the chemicals or mixtures that one wishes to use are deposited onto a filter paper and introduced to a specific solvent that is able to dissolve and carry the different dyes of the mixtures along the filter paper.
In this illustration we can observe that the solvent has moved up the filter paper and separated the dyes from the original mixtures, in this case ink spots. We can see that the separated dyes have travelled a certain distance; the blue colouring agent has travelled 4 units, while the solvent has travelled 10 units.
The ratio between the colouring agent and solvent limit defines the retention factor.
Blue spots – Retention factor = Distance travelled by coloured spot
(divided by)
Distance travelled by propanone
Rf: 4/10 =0.4
The solvent carries the dyes up to a certain distance on the filter paper, the distance travelled will indicate what kind of pigment is present. For example if two mixtures both have the same kind of pigment, using the same filter paper, both dyes will be present on the filter paper at the same distance from the solvent limit, indicating that they are the same pigment. However similar dyes will not denote the same feature, they will travel different distances thus indicating that they are different dyes, however similar they might appear.
In conclusion, chromatography separates materials by using a solvent which carries the different dyes or colouring agents present in a specific mixture. The distance travelled by each dye indicates their pigment and retention factor. By using these known properties one is able to clearly identify pigment prevalent in mixture.
Suggest problems with a simple chromatography and others methods (of chromatography) which might yield more reliable results. [D4]
Gas chromatography
Gas chromatography can be used as a tool to analyse the components of compounds by vaporisation without harming or decomposing the compounds in any way. The compounds can be separated in order to analyse the components, a relatively common process in analytical chemistry. Gas chromatography does not stop there however; testing for purity of a particular substance is also commonplace.
This type of chromatography, although similar in its aims and process, does differ from other types such as column or thin layer chromatography in that the process of separating compounds is carried out from liquid to gas.
Advantages
- Requires only very small samples
- Can separate complex mixtures into individual components effectively
- Unlike other types, the results of the analysis can be obtained fairly fast.
- It is able to detect very minute volatile mixtures unlike other types.
Drawbacks
- One of the major drawbacks is without a doubt its usefulness on substances which would be harmed if vaporised and would start to decompose should the temperature become too high, furthermore the compounds used must be able to become volatile without being harmed.
- Once the samples have been separated they cannot be used again for further analysis.
Thin layer chromatography
Similarly to paper chromatography, it uses a type of medium such as plastic or glass coated with an adsorbent material. The compounds or mixtures are deposited on the medium that has been coated and a solvent is introduced, this is known as the mobile phase as the components of the mixture start to separate.
Advantages
- It has quite a few advantages over paper chromatography these include;
- Speedier results, greater sensitivity in recognising compounds from mixtures, a smaller sample requirement and a greater variant in the available compounds to use without damaging the plate.
Disadvantages
- The results can sometimes be faint, the separated components can sometimes cause streaking, and the solvent used can have an uneven line at its limit.
Paper chromatography
This is one of the most basic of ways with which to separate components from mixtures, by simply depositing a sample of a mixture on filter paper and introducing a suitable solvent, the components can be analysed fairly easily to a rudimentary level.
Advantages
- It is one of the cheapest and easiest ways to perform a chromatography. It requires a very basic kit of tool which is cost-effective and easily obtainable. The knowledge required to perform a paper chromatography is very basic making it the simplest around.
Disadvantages
- In comparison with other types of chromatography is quite slow in obtaining a result. It is also unable to analyse complex substance, due to the nuances that must be obtained for the
- may harm it has made it quite redundant and impractical to use in the modern world.
Gas chromatography will in my opinion be the method that will give the most precise results consistently. It is able to identify extremely precise results of minute samples, a feat that none of the other chromatography techniques I have described can achieve. This is what makes gas chromatography so much more valuable in an environment which requires precision and consistent data. However it does have a major drawback and that is its inability to analyse certain chemicals due to their very fragile state, which would be harmed during the analytical process. Still, it is an invaluable piece of technology and has its place alongside other devices that are able to analyse the chemicals gas chromatography can’t.